Tag Archives: cynicism

Rhetoric

For those who watched the film on Gettsyburg on saw Jeff Daniels portray Colonel Chamberlain of Maine who saved the battle by holding the line.  He was a Professor of Rhetoric at Boudin College.  Most people today don’t even know what rhetoric is.  They think it is a term for politicians blasting each other.  In truth, rhetoric was teaching people to think logically, precisely, and intelligently, and to write and debate each other in the same way.  We have lost our skills of rhetoric in this meme driven social media opinion forming society where everyone accepts things that confirm their world view and rejects those opinions they disagree with.  I really wish everyone was taught rhetoric and cynicism at a young age.

Luckily, I was taught debate and rhetoric as a child and learned what “logical fallacies” are.  They are types of arguments that are not really valid from an intellectual standpoint but are often made.  For instance, a proponent of global warming caused by mankind my use the logical fallacy Appeal to Authority – “All scientists accept this as fact and you are no scientist.”  For one, they have no way to know that.  Second, even if true, it does not mean they are right.  All scientists once believed the Earth was the center of the universe.  An appeal to authority is a bad argument.

Another is a loaded question, such as “Do you disagree with the President because he is black or because you don’t care?”  Your two choices are racism or indifference.  The same as, “Do you still beat your wife?”  Learning rhetoric allows you to make cogent arguments from an intellectually sound basis.  WARNING:  Those who do not know rhetoric may react by getting angry and calling you names.

FallaciesPosterHigherRes

The above poster is available at the link below.  You can also zoom in there to see it better.

http://www.stumbleupon.com/su/1rrlJr/yourlogicalfallacyis.com/home?_nospa=true

rhetoric

noun    (Concise Encyclopedia)

Principles of training communicators. It may entail the study of principles and rules of composition formulated by critics of ancient times, and it can also involve the study of writing or speaking as a means of communication or persuasion. Classical rhetoric probably developed along with democracy in Syracuse (Sicily) in the 5th century BC, when dispossessed landowners argued claims before their fellow citizens. Shrewd speakers sought help from teachers of oratory, called rhetors. This use of language was of interest to philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle because the oratorical arguments called into question the relationships among language, truth, and morality. The Romans recognized separate aspects of the process of composing speeches, a compartmentalization that grew more pronounced with time. Renaissance scholars and poets studied rhetoric closely, and it was a central concern of humanism. In all times and places where rhetoric has been significant, listening and reading and speaking and writing have been the critical skills necessary for effective communication.

Leave a comment

Filed under Humor and Observations

For College Students – Welcome to Cynicism 101

I know a lot of you young college students were all excited when President Obama was elected and re-elected on a message of hope and change.  I also know many of you were excited about “free health care coverage for all Americans” after all we live in such a rich country, why not?  You were probably also excited when President Obama decided to take over student loans and not allow banks to rip you off any more on the rate increases.

[I plan to post a few cynicism lessons from time to time and promise to skewer all political parties, etc.  I am not an anarchist but I believe in personal freedom and a small government.  Unfortunately, those concepts are under attack by all parties.]

Cynicism is an attitude or state of mind characterized by a general distrust of others’ apparent motives believing that they are selfish in nature and/or displaying that themselves.

I am sorry to start your long descent into the never ending layers of cynicism, but here is what really happened:

1)  Banks were making about $57 Billion per year off student loan interest.

2)  Student loans were federalized (taken away from private banks) as a clause in the Affordable Healthcare Act (AHA), not to help you, but to get that $57 Billion to help pay for “free health care” coverage.

3)  The Obama Administration put in automatic escalator calculations in your student loan rates that would have raised them to 7.5% from their former 1-2% range, raising the federal income off student loans from $57 Billion per year to about $350 Billion.

4) When students became outraged, Congress cut this percentage to 3.86 to 6.41% depending on the category of loan, basically still tripling the private bank rate, but telling you they ‘saved you money’ by a temporary one year cap.  (http://studentaid.ed.gov/types/loans/interest-rates)

5)  The evil banks meanwhile get loaned money from the federal reserve at the fed funds rate of 8/100 ths of a percent.  That’s right.  You pay at least 3.86% to get your education, while the evil banks get money from the Obama administration at 0.08%. (http://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h15/current/)

6)  The evil banks were bailed out and posted record profits this year.

7)  Your current $54 per semester policies to cover your health while you go to college are now illegal under ACA.  Your new plans will cost you $1,800 per year, a 1500% increase, even though you are not going to be sicker than you were before.  This is so you can pay for the healthcare of older people through your premium, along with your higher cost student loans. (http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2013/11/18/students-suffer-sticker-shock-from-obamacare/)

8)  So you are going to tell them to take a hike?  Sorry, the IRS will cut off your student loans, bill you a fine and withhold your refunds if you do not participate.

9)  So far, less than 200,000 people have made it into AHA while over 15 million have had policies canceled.  Some estimates show up to 100 million policy cancellations this year, due to regulations put in place by Secretary Sebelius under AHA.

10) Evil insurance companies no longer have to take risk, sell you plans, or price things individually.  They just put three offerings on the exchanges and let the enrollees and profits roll in.

11)  The Obama Administration spent over $600 million on Healthcare.gov and it still does not function.

12)  The Obama Administration spent $4.4 Billion giving money to states for exchanges that do not work either.

Welcome to government run programs.  This is how bad and costly it is just to get started.  Just wait until they run short of money for the actual treatment of patients and see what happens then with waiting times and restriction of access to care and drugs.

cynicism2

Leave a comment

Filed under Humor and Observations